After acquiring wide receiver DK Metcalf from the Seattle Seahawks in 2025, the Pittsburgh Steelers sent George Pickens to the Dallas Cowboys. Do they now want a redo?
Two-time Pro Bowler Metcalf has underperformed since arriving in Pittsburgh and has now had another on-field incident. The WR was ejected in the third quarter of Sunday’s 19-16 road loss to the Philadelphia Eagles after poking cornerback Cooper DeJean in the eye.
It’s the third time Metcalf has been ejected in his eight-year career. He could face a suspension for the second time in his tenure in Pittsburgh. Last season, he missed two games following an altercation with a Detroit Lions fan.
Pickens, meanwhile, appears to be entering his prime with Dallas.
How has George Pickens fared since trade from Steelers?
Entering Sunday, Pickens had 143 receptions for 2,107 yards and 14 touchdown catches in 26 games with Dallas. Since 2025, he ranks eighth in the league in receptions, fourth in receiving yards, and is tied for fourth in touchdown catches.
Pickens kept adding to those totals in the Cowboys’ 51-30 win over the Tennessee Titans on Sunday, catching seven passes for 102 yards and one TD. He now has three games with 100-plus receiving yards this season.
Metcalf’s numbers are far less impressive. Entering Sunday, the pass-catcher had 94 receptions for 1,282 yards and eight TD catches in 24 games with Pittsburgh. Against Philadelphia, he caught one pass for two yards.
Why did the Steelers move on from George Pickens?
When the Steelers traded fifth-year WR Pickens, it wasn’t unwarranted. Despite many flashes in his first three seasons, Pittsburgh couldn’t ignore his maturity issues. The WR often showed up late to meetings during his time in “The Steel City,” raising questions about his dedication.
Pickens hasn’t been perfect since moving to Dallas. Last season, he beefed with “Thursday Night Football” analyst Richard Sherman after he called out his route running in a loss to the Lions. Still, he has come far since his time with the Steelers.
Metcalf, meanwhile, has regressed and is still causing trouble on the field. With that in mind, Pittsburgh may want to consider if he should remain a Steeler this offseason.
The Steelers can’t easily get out of his contract. Metcalf is in the second year of a four-year, $132M deal. It includes a potential out this offseason. Though the team would take a $35.775M dead cap hit if it activates it, the WR’s problems may force its hand.
The Steelers should be having second thoughts about dumping Pickens for Metcalf regardless.
This content was brought to you by: Yardbarker: NFL





